And so...
Yesterday at work - a long, hot, much Coke consumed day, I made an extra £5 off of the trolleys, so, thought to myself to buy a DVD. Decided not to go for the bargain bin stuff and instead got Saving Private Ryan. Interesting choice? It certainly has been. On the one hand, it is flag-waving American gung-ho fare (and the DVD special feature is stuffed to the gills with ex-WW II Army types saying the same, not to mention the overtly sentimental/patriotic music), and, as the 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die book says, it (the film) is Spielberg being his sentimental self, and accordingly allowing this side of himself to run riot, and the film being an incredibly polished work, despite claims to realism...
...there are some great moments (and I do not ususally grant that moniker to a film). Accordingly, this is when John Williams (composer) takes a hike. When there are no bugles in the background. E.G. Before the German sniper is brought down, there is a long take shot from his point of view - he sees the guy he has just shot, has the opportunity to finish him off with another shot, yet does not do so. The fact he is then shot himself only adds to the moment, in fact driving home the realism of the moment.
The 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die book mentions the film's anti-war message. Moments like that mentioned above, also when the tension created by a team of GI's meeting a group of Germans, the two groups shouting at each other to lay down their weapons, the tension created by this accordingly and that tension being broken by another group of GI's machine-gunning the Germans - drive home an anti-war message. In fact, I would argue that in many ways, music, and other sentimental touches, such as using the words of Abraham Lincoln at the end of the film are in fact used in an ironical, and non-sentimental way. What the film does do is to bring down war to a personal level - something ironically juxtaposed with the scene where the anti-tank planes appear. Relief comes, but the conflict then becomes one of impersonality.








